| 16:35 | <dminor> | (I posted this in another thread, but I'll repeat it here for visibility) For the AsyncContext proposal, I think I'd want to see host integration specified prior to stage 3. Off hand, this feels like ShadowRealms, where the host integration is a potential can of worms and it would be great to see the DOM side of things as soon as possible. Since 2.7 signals ready for testing, and I'd want to see tests for affected DOM APIs as well, I think the host integration part needs to be specified prior to 2.7. |
| 17:19 | <littledan> | Definitely DOM tests are needed as an entry requirement to Stage 3, I agree. Does that also mean that the full specification of which DOM callback APIs call within which AsyncContext.Snapshot is needed before 2.7, or is it enough to do that, along with the tests, before 3? |
| 17:19 | <littledan> | (I'm honestly fine with the 2.7 conclusion, I just want to be unambiguous here) |
| 17:20 | <littledan> | (IIRC there was some sort of suggestion during last meeting that it was OK to finalize this just before Stage 3, but I can't find it in the notes; maybe I'm making it up) |
| 17:27 | <littledan> | Sounds like we're going with, Stage 2.7 is required for the whole DOM integration proposal, so that there is a good chance for reviews from the right engineers before we declare "stability" |
| 17:27 | <littledan> | I'm happy with this conclusion |
| 18:03 | <shu> | there's the fairly clear litmus test of asking implementers in the room "is there sufficient information to implement this", right? |
| 18:04 | <shu> | that should always be yes to advance to stage 3 |